Planning for Attorney Disability or Death

Judge Pat E. Morgenstern-Clarren (N.D. Ohio – Retired) offers compelling thoughts on the seldom considered ethical, best practice and personal implications of the disability or death of an attorney with a chapter 13 practice.

You have a solo chapter 13 practice and are interviewing a candidate for a secretarial position. After you explain your office setup, the candidate asks what she should do in an emergency if she can=t reach you. You reply: “Don=t worry, I=m always available by cell phone, even on vacation.” Reassured, she accepts the job and starts right away.

The next day you have an attack of appendicitis. While you are being wheeled into the surgical suite for an emergency appendectomy, your biggest client calls the office to say that she has just been served with a complaint and motion for a temporary restraining order; the motion is set for hearing in 30 minutes. The last thing you remember before the anesthetic takes hold is someone rushing into the operating room, calling “Wait! Wait! Her secretary is on the line and has to talk to her.”

*        *        *

If you are like most chapter 13 attorneys who appear in front of me, you are a professional in every sense of the word. You attend to your clients’ legal needs, participate in community activities, and enjoy your family and friends. You would never abandon a client, leave your colleagues in the lurch, or cause unnecessary pain to the people you love. And yet, you may be running the risk of doing this every day without even knowing it. How? By failing to have a written plan for what will happen to your practice if you suddenly become disabled or die.

Few people like to think about death or disability. And when they do think about it, they tend to say: “I’m in great health” or, “my grandmother lived to 100.” This head-in-the-sand approach ignores the everyday emergencies that can interfere with legal practice, as in the anecdote above, and also ignores the realities of life. If you are in a chapter 13 solo practice or practice with a few other attorneys in an informal association, this is a critical issue to think about before the need arises, for two reasons.

The first reason to think ahead is found in the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct, a version of which has been adopted in all but two states. Rule 1:3 Diligence states that “[a] lawyer shall act with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing a client.” Comment 5 to the rule points out that:

“[t]o prevent neglect of client matters in the event of a sole practitioner=s death or disability, the duty of diligence may require that each sole practitioner prepare a plan, in conformity with applicable rules, that designates another competent lawyer to review client files, notify each client of the lawyer’s death or disability, and determine whether there is a need for immediate protective action.”

The second reason to anticipate death or disability is so that you do not hurt the people you care about the most. Last year, in this division of the Northern District of Ohio alone, we had the painful experience of seeing at least three attorneys with solo practices die unexpectedly and at relatively young ages. We also witnessed several difficult situations, short of death, where solo lawyers suddenly could not maintain their practices. None had a written plan for how to handle the work in their absence. Their clients felt abandoned and their families most likely were left with a business mess at the very time that they felt least able to address it. You would not want this to happen to your clients or your family.

Still think this is not about you? Have you ever had a “lightning flu” where you suddenly could not remember your own name or lift your head off the pillow? Gone into labor prematurely and had an unexpected C-section? What if one of these temporary disabilities struck on the day you were going to file a major case, just as the statute of limitations expired?

What to do? It’s relatively simple. Sit down and identify one or two attorneys who have the legal skills and personalities to handle your clients’ cases, then talk to those individuals to see if they are willing to serve. After you reach agreement, put it in writing. Give a copy to your covering attorneys, a copy to your staff, and a copy to your family. Put a copy with your living will and your health care power of attorney. Then, go back to enjoying your practice, knowing that you have met your professional obligations, and have protected your family from at least one of the exigencies of life.

Pat E. Morgenstern-Clarren has been a United States Bankruptcy Judge for the Northern District of Ohio since 1995. (RETIRED)

(Originally published: 2/8/2009)

No Author Biography has been linked to this Article.

Related Articles

moran_cathy
December 10, 2023
“The bankruptcy petition came to my desk for review with no entry for “clothing and wearing apparel”. Funny, I think I’d remember if I’d interviewed any naked people lately.” Although filled with Attorney Moran’s wit, there is an important lesson here! Feel free to add your own ‘naked client’ story in the comments section below the article.
Members
October 3, 2021
Jack N. Zaharopoulos was appointed as the Chapter 13 Standing Trustee for the Middle District of Pennsylvania on May 1, 2021. He succeeded Charles DeHart after his retirement. After graduating from Marquette Law School in Milwaukee in 2002, Zaharopoulos worked at a general practice firm, doing debtor and creditor bankruptcy work, family law, and even some criminal cases. After gaining...
Copy of Hildebrand-2016
December 18, 2022
Where a debtor fails to disclose to the Court or the trustee a forbearance on his mortgage that he was to pay directly, the Court would grant the trustee’s motion to modify to recapture as much as possible of the surplus funds the forbearance generated. (Kenney) In re Ilyev, 2022 WL 2965029 (Bankr. E.D. Va. July 26, 2022) Case Summary...
Members
November 1, 2020
By James J. Robinson, Chief United States Bankruptcy Judge, Northern District of Alabama Under what circumstances should the trustee object to claims (assuming a purpose would be served under § 707(a)(5))? Midland Funding, LLC v. Johnson, 137 S. Ct. 1407 (2017). This case centered around the debtor’s argument that a creditor violated the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act when it...
Members
September 8, 2019
By Angela M. Scolforo, Staff Attorney to Herbert L. Beskin, Chapter 13 Trustee (Charlottesville, VA) In Hurlburt v. Black,1 the en banc Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals overturned its prior decision in Witt,2 and held that Bankruptcy Code § 1322(c)(2) authorizes modification of some home mortgage loans through bifurcation and cram down. This enables debtors to cram down home mortgage...
Members
moran_cathy
March 3, 2024
The skills of a consumer bankruptcy lawyer must include a healthy dose of the skillset of a teacher. More on listening/communicating with Clients: Who Is Stupid Here? Why Listening Is a Bankruptcy Lawyer’s Superpower
Members
leforceheadshotcropped (2)
January 16, 2022
When do the facts justify a long bar to refiling over the 180-day period in § 109(g)? Sometimes it is Justice Stewart’s infamous words from Jacobellis v. Ohio, 378 U.S. 187 (1964)–“I know it when I see it.” Even so, a Trustee must provide evidence and authority to the Court for a long prejudice period. In In re Parson 2021...
Members
January 5, 2020
By David Cox,1 Cox Law Group, PLLC (Lynchburg, VA) Overview Filing considerations. Perfect Storm! Pensions going down. Healthcare costs going up. Home Equity high. Medical debts increasing. Limited income. Common considerations. Embarrassment. Many of the elderly are from a generation which regards bankruptcy as an indication of moral failure and shame. Confidentiality. May not want family members, including a spouse,...
Members
lynch
March 17, 2024
“The problem in the past for student loan borrowers in bankruptcy has been that hardship discharge litigation has been complex, expensive and arbitrary. . . . The new guidance has simplified the process.”
Members
April 21, 2019
Taxpayers may need to take money out of their individual retirement account or retirement plan early. However, this can trigger an additional tax on top of other income tax they may owe. Here are a few key things for taxpayers to know: Early Withdrawals. An early withdrawal normally is taking cash out of a retirement plan before the taxpayer is...

Looking to Become a Member?

ConsiderChapter13.org offers a forum to advance continuing education of consumer bankruptcy via access to insightful articles, informative webinars, and the latest industry news. Join now to benefit from expert resources and stay informed.

Webinars

These informative sessions are led by industry experts and cover a range of consumer bankruptcy topics.

Member Articles

Written by industry experts, these articles provide in-depth analysis and practical guidance on consumer bankruptcy topics.

Industry News

The Academy is the go-to source for the latest news and analysis in the Chapter 13 bankruptcy industry.

To get started, please let us know which of these best fits your current position: