Planning for Attorney Disability or Death

Judge Pat E. Morgenstern-Clarren ( N.D. Ohio) offers compelling thoughts on the seldom considered ethical, best practice and personal implications of the disability or death of an attorney with a chapter 13 practice.

You have a solo chapter 13 practice and are interviewing a candidate for a secretarial position. After you explain your office setup, the candidate asks what she should do in an emergency if she can=t reach you. You reply: “Don=t worry, I=m always available by cell phone, even on vacation.” Reassured, she accepts the job and starts right away.

The next day you have an attack of appendicitis. While you are being wheeled into the surgical suite for an emergency appendectomy, your biggest client calls the office to say that she has just been served with a complaint and motion for a temporary restraining order; the motion is set for hearing in 30 minutes. The last thing you remember before the anesthetic takes hold is someone rushing into the operating room, calling “Wait! Wait! Her secretary is on the line and has to talk to her.”

*        *        *

If you are like most chapter 13 attorneys who appear in front of me, you are a professional in every sense of the word. You attend to your clients’ legal needs, participate in community activities, and enjoy your family and friends. You would never abandon a client, leave your colleagues in the lurch, or cause unnecessary pain to the people you love. And yet, you may be running the risk of doing this every day without even knowing it. How? By failing to have a written plan for what will happen to your practice if you suddenly become disabled or die.

Few people like to think about death or disability. And when they do think about it, they tend to say: “I’m in great health” or, “my grandmother lived to 100.” This head-in-the-sand approach ignores the everyday emergencies that can interfere with legal practice, as in the anecdote above, and also ignores the realities of life. If you are in a chapter 13 solo practice or practice with a few other attorneys in an informal association, this is a critical issue to think about before the need arises, for two reasons.

The first reason to think ahead is found in the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct, a version of which has been adopted in all but two states. Rule 1:3 Diligence states that “[a] lawyer shall act with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing a client.” Comment 5 to the rule points out that:

“[t]o prevent neglect of client matters in the event of a sole practitioner=s death or disability, the duty of diligence may require that each sole practitioner prepare a plan, in conformity with applicable rules, that designates another competent lawyer to review client files, notify each client of the lawyer’s death or disability, and determine whether there is a need for immediate protective action.”

The second reason to anticipate death or disability is so that you do not hurt the people you care about the most. Last year, in this division of the Northern District of Ohio alone, we had the painful experience of seeing at least three attorneys with solo practices die unexpectedly and at relatively young ages. We also witnessed several difficult situations, short of death, where solo lawyers suddenly could not maintain their practices. None had a written plan for how to handle the work in their absence. Their clients felt abandoned and their families most likely were left with a business mess at the very time that they felt least able to address it. You would not want this to happen to your clients or your family.

Still think this is not about you? Have you ever had a “lightning flu” where you suddenly could not remember your own name or lift your head off the pillow? Gone into labor prematurely and had an unexpected C-section? What if one of these temporary disabilities struck on the day you were going to file a major case, just as the statute of limitations expired?

What to do? It’s relatively simple. Sit down and identify one or two attorneys who have the legal skills and personalities to handle your clients’ cases, then talk to those individuals to see if they are willing to serve. After you reach agreement, put it in writing. Give a copy to your covering attorneys, a copy to your staff, and a copy to your family. Put a copy with your living will and your health care power of attorney. Then, go back to enjoying your practice, knowing that you have met your professional obligations, and have protected your family from at least one of the exigencies of life.

Pat E. Morgenstern-Clarren has been a United States Bankruptcy Judge for the Northern District of Ohio since 1995.



(Originally published: 2/8/2009)

No Author Biography has been linked to this Article.

Related Articles

October 27, 2019
By Lawrence R. Ahern, III, Brown & Ahern (Nashville, TN) Part IV Two More Things Trustees Should Know About the Small Business Reorganization Act of 2019 Introduction Four bankruptcy-related bills were enacted during the 116th Congress and signed into law on August 23, 2019.1 The legislation affected both business and consumer cases. One bill, the Small Business Reorganization Act of...
September 29, 2019
By The Honorable Hannah Blumenstiel Yes, MORE on SBRA. We realize that to attorneys February of 2020 seems a LONG way away but it really isn’t. We are building our library on this important legislation so it is available when YOU are ready for it. In this week’s installation, Judge Blumenstiel, analyzes the legislation. The first two and a half...
February 16, 2020
By Cathy Moran, Esq. (Redwood City, CA) One of the mysteries of Chapter 13 is why mortgage lenders don’t send an IRS 1098 for mortgage payments made through a Chapter 13 plan. And without that reminder piece of paper, our clients don’t realize that much of what the trustee pays to mortgage creditors is deductible interest. Miss that deduction and...
September 15, 2019
By The Honorable William Houston Brown (Retired) Manufactured home did not become accession to real property. The creditor holding security interest in a manufactured home objected to confirmation, on the basis that § 1322(b)(2)’s anti-modification provision prevented bifurcation of its claim into secured and unsecured parts. The Eighth Circuit noted that the Bankruptcy Code does not resolve the issue of...
April 21, 2019
By Henry E. Hildebrand, III, Chapter 13 Standing Trustee (Nashville, TN) Section I. Student Loans, Part I Statutory Suggestions When the Commission asked participants to identify the most important issue in consumer bankruptcy, all three committees were told the same thing: the role of bankruptcy in the field of student loans. All three committees looked at the issue and proposed...
March 10, 2019
Victims of March 3rd tornadoes and severe storms in Alabama have until July 31, 2019, to file certain individual and business tax returns and make certain tax payments. The IRS is offering this relief to any Major Disaster Declaration area designated by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) as qualifying for individual assistance. Currently, this only includes Lee County, Alabama,...
March 17, 2019
By Wm. Houston Brown, United States Bankruptcy Judge (Retired) Confirmation - Bankruptcy court could not sua sponte object to confirmation. Distinguishing between “self-executing” provisions of the Code and those sections that were not “self-executing,” and discussing Espinosa’s impact on that distinction, District Court held that the bankruptcy court could not sua sponte object to confirmation based on the above- median...
February 10, 2019
By Leo G. Spanos, Senior Staff Attorney to Martha G. Bronitsky, Chapter 13 Trustee, Northern District of California (Oakland Division) Courts around the country are split on whether property acquired post-chapter 13 confirmation remains property of the estate or vests in the debtor for all purposes absent contrary language in the plan or confirmation order under 11 U.S.C. § 1327(b).1...
Academy Circle Logo Final
February 12, 2023
Previously the Emeritus Trustees (“ETC”) were asked to comment on “How to Manage Unprofessional and Discourteous Attorneys”. We now turn to ETC to share their collective wisdom when addressing the issues raised by incompetent, unprepared, and negligent bankruptcy counsel. Chapter 13 Trustees are required to administer cases in accordance with the duties set forth in 11 U.S.C. Sec. 1302 and...
July 12, 2020
July 10, 2020, the CFPB released a report examining recent trends in debt settlement and credit counseling. Many Americans struggle with their debts, especially during times of crisis. Today’s report documents changes over time in how consumers have used these debt relief options for unsecured debt. Using the Bureau’s Consumer Credit Panel (CCP), a nationally representative sample of approximately five...