Practice Pointers for Arguing Motions

By William Sawyer, Chief U.S. Bankruptcy Judge for the Middle District of Alabama (Montgomery) (Used with permission. Court News and Views, Volume 18, October 2020)

Lawyers who practice regularly in bankruptcy court invariably make many appearances at motion dockets. This article provides practice pointers to lawyers who do not practice often in this Court to familiarize them with our procedures and perhaps provide a brush up for those that do.

  1. A well-drafted motion or objection is the first step. The motion should recite facts which relate to the case at hand. Boilerplate motions are not well received and may result in a denial, without prejudice, leaving the lawyer to begin anew.
  2. The motion should state specifically: (a) what the pleader wants; and (b) why the Court should grant the relief requested.
  3. If there is an opposing party, counsel should reach out and attempt to resolve the matter. It is a poor reflection on both counsel when the Court calls a mater which is not resolved and counsel for the parties have not talked to one another.
  4. Settlements are encouraged. Most matters are either settled or are granted by default. If a matter is settled, one counsel should be assigned to contact the Court by e-mail at least one day in advance. The Court has an administrative order on this point that should be observed. If a matter is settled more than 24 hours in advance, and an e-mail was sent to the appropriate Court e-mail, counsel need not attend the hearing.
  5. Agreed orders should be submitted using the Court’s prescribed e-order process. Directions are provided on the Court’s website.
  6. Is a continuance to be requested? The reason for the continuance and the amount of time needed to resolve the matter should be provided. Multiple requests for continuance are not well received.
  7. Counsel should interview their clients before the hearing. It is bad form for counsel in open court to be asking his client open ended questions as to why chapter 13 plan payments have not been made.
  8. When a matter is called, moving counsel should speak first and advise the Court as to the status of the matter. Is it resolved? Will an e-order be submitted? If it is not resolved, is an evidentiary hearing necessary? If so, what issues have to be tried? Has counsel attempted in good faith to resolve any issues not in dispute? If there are legal issues to be decided, will briefs be necessary? At this stage of the proceedings, the lawyers are expected to know more than the Court about the matter at hand and should be able to explain, succinctly, how the matter is to be resolved.
  9. If an evidentiary hearing is necessary, counsel should provide a good faith estimate as to how much time he expects the Court will need to hear the matter –an hour, a day, a week? How many witnesses will be called? Will there be documentary exhibits? If so, how many? A handful, several dozen, several hundred, more than a thousand?
  10. Talking out of turn is in bad form. Moving counsel goes first. The exception is if opposing counsel no longer contests the motion and is giving up. After moving counsel has been heard, any other parties who support the motion may be heard. Next, opposing counsel is heard. Moving counsel may reply if she wants to be heard again. Generally, that is it. We generally do not hear further argument.
  11. Motions to reconsider should be filed only for extraordinary reasons, and only where counsel has met the appropriate legal standard. A motion to reconsider simply to take another bite at the apple is in bad form.
  12. Counsel should address the merits of the matter at hand and not engage in ad hominem attacks on opposing counsel or opposing parties.
  13. Counsel should be addressed by the appropriate title and surname, i.e. Mr. Jones or Dr. Walker, not Bubba or Gus. The Court should be addressed as “Your Honor” or “Judge Sawyer,” not, “Hey Judge.”
  14. When appearing on a telephonic docket counsel should keep their phones muted until their matter is called. Guidance for muting your phones is found on our website.
  15. Counsel should be guided at all times by notions of professionalism and collegiality.

This article provides practice pointers for lawyers who practice in our Court. Using these pointers should help all of us move our cases along quickly, efficiently, and collegially.

________________________

The Honorable William R. Sawyer was appointed as a Bankruptcy Judge for the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Middle District of Alabama on May 24, 1999. He served as Chief Judge from 1999 to 2006 and a second term from 2013 to 2020. His chambers are in Montgomery, Alabama, with satellite courthouses in Dothan and Opelika, Alabama. Judge Sawyer served as the Eleventh Circuit representative to the Board of Governors of the National Conference of Bankruptcy Judges from 2014 to 2016. Judge Sawyer graduated from Valparaiso University School of Law in 1982 and was admitted to the Indiana bar the same year. Upon graduation, Judge Sawyer joined the law firm of Clifford, Claudon, Alexa and Sawyer, in the private practice of law in Valparaiso, Indiana, until 1986. In June of 1986, he accepted a position as a Trial Attorney for the United States Department of Justice, Tax Division, as a Trial Attorney, working in Washington, DC. In 1989, Sawyer accepted a position as an Assistant United States Attorney in the Southern District of Alabama, serving there until 1999, when he was appointed to the bankruptcy bench. He was admitted to the Alabama bar in 1991. Judge Sawyer has served as an Adjunct Professor at Faulkner University, Jones School of Law, teaching bankruptcy law since 2005. Judge Sawyer served as an Adjunct Professor at Huntington College, teaching business law, from 2002 to 2006. He lectures and writes frequently on bankruptcy related issues. He authored two articles for the Alabama Law: (1) Top 10 Things Never to Say to a Judge, 72 Ala. Law 476, November 2011; (2) Civil Actions and Bankruptcy Proceedings: A Collision of Two Very Different Worlds, 68 Ala. Law 290, July 2007.

No Author Biography has been linked to this Article.

Related Articles

Copy of Hildebrand-2016
July 30, 2023
By Henry E. Hildebrand, III, Chapter 13 Standing Trustee for the Middle District of Tennessee (Nashville) Post-petition, pre-conversion equity that accrues in a debtor’s residence during the pendency of a Chapter 13 plan is property of the estate in the Chapter 7 estate following conversion.  (Hastings) Goetz v. Weber (In re Goetz), 651 B.R. 292 (8th Cir. BAP, June 1,...
Members
June 16, 2019
By Lawrence R. Ahern III, Brown & Ahern (Nashville, TN) Introduction – The Taggart Ruling Last year, the Ninth Circuit in In re Taggart1 ruled that an act in violation of the discharge injunction did not empower a court to find a creditor in contempt, if the creditor believed in good faith that the discharge injunction did not apply—even if...
Members
hayes
March 24, 2024
Bankruptcy Court in Texas awards sanctions of $825,940.55 for bad faith filing and prosecution of a proof of claim. (Yes it’s an 11 but still, $825k!)
Members
August 11, 2019
By Selwyn D. Whitehead, Esq. Because inquiring minds need to know; below is a discussion of the Johnson Publishing Company, LLC’s Chapter 7 Liquidation Bankruptcy, Case No. 19-10236, which was filed in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division in Chicago on April 9, 2019, and its week-long auction from July 22-24, 2019. Here's...
Members
M Joseph Photo 2-1-22
August 28, 2022
An attorney meets with a potential client about a recent auto accident personal injury claim. The client suffered severe injuries and may be entitled to a large award. The client fails to mention that he is a debtor in an active bankruptcy. The client also has failed to advise his bankruptcy attorney about the personal injury claim. The debtor/client does...
June 2, 2019
By Tammy E. Stickley and Francis J. DiCesare, Staff Attorneys for Margaret A. Burks, Esq. Chapter 13 Standing Trustee (Cincinnati, OH) In a media age in which people expect to be told when “spoilers” are ahead, this summary needs no such warning. Courts have little patience for debtors who surrender collateral – especially real estate – then oppose the foreclosure...
Members
NBR cropped 2
August 7, 2022
Dear Readers: When a judge issues a 28-page opinion sanctioning a lawyer, usually that means that the lawyer has done so many things wrong that he or she has caused the judge to roll up his or her respective sleeves (probably shirt-sleeves, although the image of robe-sleeves also works for me) to deal with the mess. And in Shiheiber v....
Members
October 18, 2020
By James J. Robinson, Chief United States Bankruptcy Judge, Northern District of Alabama Can the trustee challenge the debtor’s attorney’s fee? In re Rodriguez Perez, 2018 WL 3655656 (Bankr. D.P.R. 2018). In this case, the chapter 13 trustee asked the bankruptcy court to assess the contract between the debtor and counsel under § 526-528. The trustee alleged that the contract...
Members
April 28, 2019
By Leo G. Spanos, Senior Staff Attorney to Martha G. Bronitsky, Chapter 13 Trustee, Northern District of California (Oakland Division) 1. Background & Purpose of Means Test One of the most significant changes introduced BAPCPA is the requirement of a means test to determine whether a debtor qualifies for Chapter 7 relief or, if not, how much a debtor must...
Members
Jeffrey-Fraser
August 13, 2023
In this brief synopsis, Fraser compares Lac du Flambeauto a case from the Middle District Court of North Carolina and its connection to the automatic stay.
Members

Looking to Become a Member?

ConsiderChapter13.org offers a forum to advance continuing education of consumer bankruptcy via access to insightful articles, informative webinars, and the latest industry news. Join now to benefit from expert resources and stay informed.

Webinars

These informative sessions are led by industry experts and cover a range of consumer bankruptcy topics.

Member Articles

Written by industry experts, these articles provide in-depth analysis and practical guidance on consumer bankruptcy topics.

Industry News

The Academy is the go-to source for the latest news and analysis in the Chapter 13 bankruptcy industry.

To get started, please let us know which of these best fits your current position: