College May Keep Tuition Money Paid by Bankrupt Parents, Judge Rules

By Katy Stech
Updated Aug. 11, 2016 7:50 p.m. ET

Sacred Heart University can keep money in bankruptcy of Steven and Lori Palladino tied to Ponzi scheme

A federal bankruptcy judge ruled that Sacred Heart University can keep roughly $65,000 in tuition money in a legal battle that’s grown more common as the cost of college rises and tuition payments become a popular target of bankruptcy trustees.

U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Melvin Hoffman ruled that Steven and Lori Palladino benefited from paying their daughter’s tuition at the private Connecticut university. The decision allows the school to avoid returning the money—paid between March 2012 and March 2014—to a court-appointed trustee who sought the money to pay debts as part of the Massachusetts couple’s 2014 bankruptcy.

“A parent can reasonably assume that paying for a child to obtain an undergraduate degree will enhance the financial well-being of the child which in turn will confer an economic benefit on the parent,” Judge Hoffman wrote in the nine-page ruling.

With his ruling on Wednesday, Judge Hoffman became the first judge in recent years to weigh in on bankruptcy trustees who sue universities—and sometimes, college students themselves—to take back tuition that had been paid by parents years before. Trustees argue that because bankrupt parents don’t benefit from paying children’s college tuition, those payments should be taken back and made available to pay the parents’ other debts. Most colleges have settled, agreeing to return a total of at least $276,434.80 since 2014, a Wall Street Journal analysis found.

Under the U.S. bankruptcy code, trustees can sue to take back money spent in the several years before a bankruptcy filing if a trustee finds the person didn’t get “reasonably equivalent value” for that expense. In the case of a child’s tuition payment, trustees argue the bankrupt parent didn’t get the value for the expenditure, but rather the child did.

In the Palladino case, bankruptcy trustee Mark DeGiacomo argued that Sacred Heart University’s tuition payments should be redirected to victims of a multimillion-dollar Ponzi scheme that Mr. Palladino orchestrated. He pleaded guilty to federal and state criminal charges, and in 2014 a Massachusetts court sentenced him to 10 years in prison, according to bankruptcy-court documents. Ms. Palladino pleaded guilty and was sentenced to five years of probation.

University lawyer Elizabeth Austin said Wednesday that Judge Hoffman’s decision speaks to “the outrage over trustees that are pursuing universities when they have provided an education to young adults that their parents pay for in good faith.”

Mr. DeGiacomo on Thursday declined to comment.

In other cases, judges have disagreed on whether the colleges should return tuition. In 2011, Marquette University lost a battle over $21,527 in tuition when U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Thomas Tucker in Detroit ruled that the value to a student’s parent wasn’t “concrete and quantifiable.”

Several federal lawmakers last year proposed to ban such lawsuits, saying it is up to a parent to decide whether to pay a child’s education instead of other bills. The measure hasn’t gained much traction.

No Author Biography has been linked to this Article.

Related Articles

April 19, 2020
By Michael McCormick, Senior Partner, McCalla Raymer Leibert Pierce, LLC (Roswell, GA) H.R. 748, also known as the CARES Act (herein, “the Act”), was enacted into law on March 27, 2020. The Act is meant to address the economic fallout of the Coronavirus pandemic. The Act contains numerous consumer protections, including several pertaining to residential mortgages. Relief from Foreclosure Section...
Members
May 19, 2019
By Henry E. Hildebrand, III, Chapter 13 Standing Trustee (Nashville, TN) Homeowner association fees that obligate homeowners of condominium and planned unit developments can be a substantial obligation that accrue on a monthly basis. These obligations are generally a burden when a debtor files for bankruptcy relief. To be fair, homeowners’ associations provide a significant benefit to homeowners. Exterior maintenance,...
Members
July 14, 2019
By Beverly M. Burden, Standing Chapter 13 Trustee (Lexington, KY) An unscheduled creditor without notice of the bankruptcy case was denied an extension of time to file a proof of claim pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule 3002(c)(6)(A) in a recent opinion from the Eastern District of Kentucky. In the case of In re Fryman,1 the debtor did not include creditor Kentucky...
Members
April 14, 2019
By William J. Purdy, III, Simmons & Purdy (Soquel, CA) Hundreds of thousands of taxpayers in the past few weeks have looked at or at least thought about, Form 1099-A or Form 1099-C documents they have received. Some arrived in the tax year a debt was allegedly cancelled. Others are issued by financial instructions many years after they should have...
Members
June 21, 2020
By The Honorable William Houston Brown (Retired) Portion of divorce award was priority domestic support claim and portion dischargeable unsecured claim. Applying Third Circuit’s factors from In re Gianakas, 917 F.2d 759 (3d Cir. 1990), and considering special master’s intent in divorce proceedings, one-third of former spouse’s claim was priority domestic support but two- thirds was reclassified as general unsecured...
Members
August 18, 2019
By Regina Logsdon, Executive Director, The Academy d/b/a ConsiderChapter13.org Robert (“Bob”) G. Drummond has been the only standing Chapter 13 Trustee for the District of Montana since 1992. Originally from Montana, Mr. Drummond graduated from Montana State University with a Bachelor of Science degree in Agricultural Business, and received a Juris Doctorate in Law with Honors from the University of...
October 20, 2019
(First published here on August 19, 2019. Used with permission.) By Daniel Cohn, Esq., Legal Department, Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. General Rule: No Primary Residence Mortgage Changes The general rule in bankruptcy is that debtors cannot cram down loans secured only by mortgages on their primary residences. But wait, “what’s a cram down?” you ask. For non-bankruptcy folks, a cram...
Members
moran_cathy
July 17, 2022
Mention keeping time records to a bankruptcy lawyer and you’re likely met with expressions of utter revulsion. All too many assert that the major appeal of being a bankruptcy lawyer is precisely that they don’t have to keep time. Between flat fee deals with clients, and no look fees in Chapter 13, they feel liberated from the clock and the...
Members
February 7, 2021
By Ken Siomos, Staff Attorney for Marsha L. Combs-Skinner (Newman, IL) The December 2020 Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, more commonly known as the second covid-19 stimulus bill, contains a few bankruptcy related provisions, but none stood out more with respect to Chapter 13 than the newly created § 1328(i). This provision provides that a court may grant a full 1328(a)...
Members
November 29, 2020
By Lawrence R. Ahern III, Brown & Ahern (Nashville, TN) PART VI – CONSUMER FORECLOSURE PROCEDURES (CONCLUSION) Introduction In the consumer bankruptcy field, trustees and debtors' counsel often are uncomfortable with the rules in Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC). In this series for the NACTT Academy, we have looked at numerous topics involving the interplay of Article...
Members