Potential Ninth Circuit Decision in the Making: Where do Voluntary Contributions to Retirement Fit in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Plans?

By Ansley Owens, Contributing Writer and Intern for The Academy (Nashville, TN)

Trustees and debtors should keep an eye on the Ninth Circuit and the nine states it covers regarding the treatment of voluntary contributions to retirement plans.

A recent decision in the Western District of Washington held contributions to an employee retirement plan should be excluded from the computation of current monthly income and, therefore, not deducted from disposable income in the Means Test. In re Vu, No. 15-41405 (Bankr. W.D. June 16, 2015).

Anh-Thu Thi Vu was an above-median debtor . . .

It looks like you are not signed in or registered! This content is only available to members.

Or sign in below:

No Author Biography has been linked to this Article.

Tribute to Barbara P. Foley, Esq.

Hon. Scott W. Dales

September 15, 2024

“ . . . Barb quickly put my concerns to rest . . . . She was respectful but firm, of course, and I could also detect a nurturing side. We talked about, of all things, my relationship with my mother (let's not go there!) and I foresaw that Barb would be making her mark on our district.” We will miss you, Barb!!!

U.S. Trustee Program to Implement Virtual Section 341 Meetings of Creditors Nationwide

The Academy

September 3, 2023

These virtual 341 meetings via Zoom will be implemented on a rolling basis through early 2024.

Claim Preclusion and the Opportunities for Mischief

Cathy Moran

March 27, 2022

I’ve been having nightmares about the 9th Circuit’s decision in Siegel for 20 years. Broad strokes, Siegel (143 F.3d 525 (9th Cir. 1998) holds that a filed claim in a no asset bankruptcy case to which no one objects is entitled to preclusive effect in subsequent litigation by . . . It looks like you are not signed in or...

Members

Critical Case Comment–84 Months: Lifesaver or Anchor?

Henry E. Hildebrand, III

February 12, 2023

Section 1329(c), as it currently exists, forecloses the ability of Chapter 13 debtor to modify a confirmed plan to alter the plan payment amount while maintaining an extended plan, previously approved under the CARES Act. (Hanan) In re Nelson, 2022 WL 6795096 (Bankr. E.D. Wis. October 11, 2022) Case Summary Immediately after the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, Congress sought...

Members

Musings from a Hapless Former BAP Law Clerk: Part 3 – the Standards of Review

M. Jonathan Hayes

February 15, 2026

My goal with this series of short articles is to convince you that the fear of appeals is misplaced.

Members

A Tribute to Joan Truman

The Academy

December 21, 2025

“She taught us all how it looks to love well by how she lived.”

Critical Case Comment–“No Realistic Future Prospects”

Henry E. Hildebrand, III

March 26, 2023

A 34-year-old Chapter 7 debtor could discharge his student loan obligation by establishing that he could not reasonably make payments on the balance, could not maintain a reasonable standard of living, and because the expiration of his payment term had already passed, his standard of living was likely to persist, with no realistic future prospects. (Silverstein) In re Wolfson, No....

Members

Property of the Estate or Appeal Rights for Sale?

M. Jonathan Hayes

January 19, 2025

Atty Hayes takes a look at a very interesting aspect of law we probably don’t think about on a regular basis. Are appeals for sale? “. . . maybe the answer is that the right to appeal is always property of the estate and may be sold to the opposing party.”

Members

TFS Bill Pay Announces New Attorney Report Center

November 21, 2021

TFS Bill Pay has launched a new powerful tool to help you succeed; the Attorney Report Center located in your AttorneyPortal. In the current bankruptcy environment, it is absolutely essential that your firm receives all of the compensation for the valuable work it has already done. TFS now provides you with pre-set, real-time reports to confirm your clients’ payments, which...

From the Editor – Classification

August 9, 2020

By The Honorable William Houston Brown (Retired) Separate classification and preferential treatment of student loan debt. The Chapter 13 trustee and debtors’ attorney attempted to change the traditional approach in the District, seeking approval of a permissible fair discrimination in favor of student loan debt in plans so long as the preferential treatment and discrimination was no more than 20%....

Members

Potential Ninth Circuit Decision in the Making: Where do Voluntary Contributions to Retirement Fit in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Plans?

Link to Post:

It looks like you are not signed in or registered! This content is only available to members.

Or sign in below:

Related Articles

Tribute to Barbara P. Foley, Esq.

U.S. Trustee Program to Implement Virtual Section 341 Meetings of Creditors Nationwide

Claim Preclusion and the Opportunities for Mischief

Critical Case Comment–84 Months: Lifesaver or Anchor?

Musings from a Hapless Former BAP Law Clerk: Part 3 – the Standards of Review

A Tribute to Joan Truman

Critical Case Comment–“No Realistic Future Prospects”

Property of the Estate or Appeal Rights for Sale?

TFS Bill Pay Announces New Attorney Report Center

From the Editor – Classification

Academy

Members

Website

Legal

Looking to Become a Member?

Webinars

Member Articles

Industry News

To get started, please let us know which of these best fits your current position: