Debtor Math

By Helen M. Morris, Chapter 13 Trustee, Northern and Southern Districts of West Virginia

debtormathDebtor math baffles me.   I work base 10 daily; I am even competent in base 6 and can do binary.  But I just can’t get the hang of debtor math.

For example, in a motion filed by an experienced debtor attorney:

“The debtors request permission to settle with the insurance carrier for $7,974 and to use $8,995 of the proceeds to purchase a replacement vehicle.” (No, the figures weren’t transposed.  The insurance settlement was $7,974.00.)

In an order drafted by the same attorney with respect to the treatment of a Special Class unsecured claim:

“[Creditor’s] claim will be kept at $188.71 times 28 months or $4,975.88.”  Of course, $188.71 times 28 is $5,283.88.   Every staffer who handled that order came to me with a question—is the claim to be paid at $188.71 for 28 months or a total of $4,975.88?  I raised the issue at confirmation and the answer from the Court was that the creditor was to be paid $4,975.88 at the rate of $188.71 for as many months as necessary.

That same attorney filed a motion to modify a confirmed plan (He always calls it amending the plan, but that’s another story.) in which he wanted to extend the plan from 36 months to 60 months and add the mortgage to be paid through the trustee.  I had no problem with the concept, but with his math.  (DUH!)  I filed a response that stated that the modified plan payments needed to be $1,290.00 for the remaining 39 months if the plan were extended.   At the hearing, he persuaded the Judge to extend the plan to 47 months and set the plan payments at $1,070.00 for the remaining period.  The plan is now short the sum of $8,013.02.  Trustee’s motion for reconsideration has been filed.

One expects math problems with pro se debtors, and one of my classic cases was filed by an infrequent Chapter 13 filer–now a debtor himself, pro se, of course.  (I guess the good news/bad news  for his clients is that he isn’t doing  a better job with his own case than he does on theirs.)

Monthly disposable income is $126.81.  Plan payments are $361.10 per month for 60 months.  Two mortgages are to be paid through the plan.  One mortgage has monthly payments of $838.15 per month and a pre-petition arrearage of $6,091.81.   The second mortgage has monthly payments of $457.38 per month.

It’s only short about $74,000.00—and that’s just to pay administrative and secured claims.  There are $86,524.00 in unsecured claims.

Are there coupons I’m supposed to be using to stretch the debtor dollar?

Of course, the creditors aren’t always on top of the calculator either.  In a recent case, the system showed that there was a balance on the pre-petition arrearage unpaid as well as a post-petition arrearage.  (We are a conduit jurisdiction now, but weren’t at the time the case was filed.  The ongoing mortgage payments were added post-confirmation in resolution of a motion for stay relief.)  Two letters to the debtors and their counsel providing documentation (proof of claim filed by the creditor and a copy of order setting the post-petition arrearage as well as payment history to the affected creditor on the pre-petition, post-petition and on-going payments through my office) brought a fax to me from the creditor which simply stated that the debtors are current on the mortgage.

I responded to the creditor with a letter pointing out that I showed there were balances due on the arrearage claims and I could not use a fax to “correct” my numbers.  The creditor’s attorney called my office and told the staffer who answered the phone that other trustees file a Notice of Final Cure and the creditor will respond to that.  He didn’t understand why I couldn’t do that.  Never mind that I had previously talked to the attorney and explained that I was still showing balances due—thus, I couldn’t file a pleading with the Court stating that the arrearages were cured.  It took two more phone calls before the creditor finally filed something with the Court.

The same creditor, however, in a case in which I was showing the debtor current and the default cured, filed a response that the debtor wasn’t current and indicated an amount due which didn’t correspond with anything of record.  I filed a Reply.  Subsequently, my office received a phone call from a bank employee saying that my reply was correct and they weren’t going to attend the hearing.

My office manager is growing concerned.  She has her mortgage with that bank.

______________________

2013-01-26 16.11.10-1Helen M. Morris has been the Chapter 13 trustee for the Northern and Southern Districts of West Virginia since October 1, 1996. Prior to her appointment, she was in private practice in Huntington, WV, where she served as a Chapter 7 panel trustee in addition to representing both debtors and creditors in bankruptcy matters; but not in the same case. She has a Bachelor’s degree from Marshall University in Huntington, WV, and her law degree from Vanderbilt University School of Law in Nashville, TN.

No Author Biography has been linked to this Article.

Related Articles

January 2, 2022
Attorney General Merrick B. Garland recently appointed Mary Ida Townson as the U.S. Trustee for Florida, Georgia, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands (Region 21). Ms. Townson assumed her duties in June and replaced Nancy Gargula, who is the U.S. Trustee in Region 10 and who had served as the interim U.S. Trustee in Region 21...
beskin
October 22, 2023
Upon this auspicious occasion, seeing before us this eloquence of attorneys, let us recount the mighty deeds of one Herbert Lee Beskin. WHEREAS, Herbert was born and began his legal career in the last century (or we presume); and WHEREAS, a double Hoo, Herbert graduated from the University of Virginia with a B.A. in 1972, and stayed in Charlottesville to...
memorialday
May 28, 2023
Memorial Day 2023 Honoring the Sacrifices of All Who Served
JamesDavis
February 25, 2024
“Over the years courts have struggled to apply the lien-avoidance provisions under § 522(f) to jointly owned property. . . .Things get even more confusing when the debtor owns property as a tenancy by the entireties. That antiquated form of ownership has odd characteristics that do not fit well into the § 522(f) calculation.”
Members
January 13, 2019
By John P. Gustafson, United States Bankruptcy Judge, Northern District of Ohio, Western Division (Toledo, OH) Click here for Part 1 of 6 Click here for Part 2 of 6 Click here for Part 4 of 6 Click here for Part 5 of 6
Members
Copy of Hildebrand-2016
July 24, 2022
Secured creditor in a Chapter 13 case entitled to relief from the stay due to lack of adequate protection where the creditor neglects to file a proof of claim and, as a consequent, received no payments under a Chapter 13 plan. (Conley) Weyer v. Valley Communities Credit Union, 2022 WL 1597293 (W.D. Wis. May 19, 2022) Case Summary Dana and...
Members
July 11, 2021
Kara K. Gendron, Esquire, Mott & Gendron Law (Harrisburg, PA) A “kill switch” is a device which can be used to disable a machine or program. They have been used for years in a myriad of safety measures, such as shutting down machinery in the event of an emergency, or to prevent the theft of a machine or data. Some...
Members
balboa
August 20, 2023
Wishing our dear friend and colleague, Isabel Balboa, a hearty congratulations on her upcoming retirement. As many of you know, Isabel came to the United States from Cuba at the age of 6 with her mother and sisters.  Upon leaving Cuba, they were forced to leave everything behind for fear that they would be caught and detained.  Her father was...
February 17, 2019
By Lawrence R. Ahern III, Brown & Ahern (Nashville, TN) PART II: More Supreme Court Action on Arbitration Introduction Click here for Part I Click here for Part III Click here for Part IV What is the effect of an . . . It looks like you are not signed in or registered! This content is only available to members....
Members
January 24, 2021
On October 1, 2019, John G. Jansing was appointed Chapter 13 Standing Trustee for the Southern District of Ohio at Dayton. John took over from Jeff Kellner, who retired and moved to New Hampshire. John had some great mentors: Herb Beskin in Charlottesville, Marge Burks in Cincinnati and Faye English in Columbus. John toured Herb’s office in January 2020 and...

Looking to Become a Member?

ConsiderChapter13.org offers a forum to advance continuing education of consumer bankruptcy via access to insightful articles, informative webinars, and the latest industry news. Join now to benefit from expert resources and stay informed.

Webinars

These informative sessions are led by industry experts and cover a range of consumer bankruptcy topics.

Member Articles

Written by industry experts, these articles provide in-depth analysis and practical guidance on consumer bankruptcy topics.

Industry News

The Academy is the go-to source for the latest news and analysis in the Chapter 13 bankruptcy industry.

To get started, please let us know which of these best fits your current position: