Hann v. Educational Credit Mgmt. Corp. (In re Hann), No. NH 11-084, 2012 WL 3195135, at *2, *10–*11 (B.A.P. 1st Cir. Aug. 7, 2012) (Hillman, Feeney, Hoffman)

Disallowance of claim of ECMC with finding that $0 was due is preclusive of collection of any student loan debt after discharge notwithstanding that dischargeability was not at issue during claim objection hearing. ECMC filed a proof of claim for $55,000. The debtor objected. ECMC neither responded to the claim objection nor attended the evidentiary hearing. Debtor put on evidence that the student loans had been paid in full before the petition. The bankruptcy court order sustained the debtor’s objection and stated “‘[t]his [c]ourt allows the claim of ECMC in the amount of $0.00.’” After completion of payments and discharge, ECMC took collection action and debtor sought contempt. “The issue is not whether a nondischargeable debt can be discharged by virtue of its disallowance, but whether there is a debt at all where the claim has been disallowed on the grounds of pre-petition payment in full. By definition, where there is no claim, there is no debt and nothing is discharged. . . . [B]y filing the Claim Objection, Hann invoked the appropriate procedural mechanism provided by the Bankruptcy Code to obtain a determination of both the validity and amount of the Claim. . . . [T]he bankruptcy court conducted a thorough review . . . . This process yielded a ruling that the amount of the Claim on the date of Hann’s bankruptcy petition was zero. . . . The court having concluded that there is no extant claim, there can be no liability on a claim and hence no debt . . . . [T]he [order sustaining the claim objection] which is the subject of this appeal effectively precluded any further attempt by ECMC to collect on the alleged student loan debt.”

No Author Biography has been linked to this Article.

Related Articles

February 26, 2023
This Part 6 continues1 an analysis of judicial developments with a significant decision on finality of a Chapter 13 confirmation order. In re Bozeman Section 1327 of the Bankruptcy Code provides that a confirmed Chapter 13 plan binds the debtor and creditors to its terms.2 In In re Bozeman,3 the Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit looked at a...
NBR cropped 2
February 18, 2024
This month, Prof. Rapoport looks at the question: What should happen when the Rule 2016 statement on compensation conflicts with the SOFA #16?
Dynele Schinker-Kuharich
July 14, 2024
“Attending the NACTT Annual Seminar provided the opportunity to catch up with Chapter 13 colleagues from around the country who are quickly becoming good friends; and to build relationships with colleagues who have recently joined our niche’ of the bankruptcy field.”
May 16, 2021
By Cathy Moran, Esq., (Redwood City, CA) Have I got a story for you. A rousing tale of schedules, hearings, frustrations, and ultimately fortunes, traceable to a good story in the fee application. Maybe that's a bit overblown, but I'm telling this story with a purpose. Good stories lead to fair compensation for bankruptcy attorneys. Fee applications aren't hard Filing...
May 12, 2019
By Margaret A. Burks, Esq., Chapter 13 Trustee (Cincinnati, OH) I was recently asked to expound on a “Day in the Life of a Chapter 13 Trustee.” Then Regina (Logsdon, Executive Director of ConsiderChapter13.org) asked me to write an article for the Academy. I believe in fate so here goes. Please see ‘Effective Communication Guide.’ It came out about four...
July 12, 2020
By Daryl J. Smith, Senior Staff Attorney to Sylvia Ford Brown, Chapter 13 Trustee (Memphis, TN) and Katherine L. Rea, Staff Attorney to Pamela Simmons-Beasley, Chapter 13 Trustee (Columbia, SC) Is there ever a reason to oppose a voluntary dismissal of a chapter 13 that has not been converted from a chapter 7? Maybe. But will you be successful? Probably...
June 9, 2019
Floods, wildfires, hurricanes, tornados and other natural disasters happen quickly and often with little warning. No one can prevent these disasters from happening, but people can prepare for them. Here are some things taxpayers can do to help protect their financial safety should a disaster occur. Taxpayers should: Update emergency plans. A disaster can strike any time. Personal and business...
March 8, 2020
Rebecca A. (Becky) Herr was appointed Chapter 13 Standing Trustee for the District of Maryland on October 1, 2019 and maintains her offices in Annapolis. Ms. Herr’s appointment came on the heels of the retirement of Chapter 13 Standing Trustee Nancy Spencer-Grigsby. But Herr is no stranger to NACTT, The Academy, and the Chapter 13 Trustee community. So, let’s start...
June 18, 2023
Lac Du Flambeau Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians et al. v. Coughlin Supreme Court rules in favor of borrower of tribal loan –Chapter 13 stay applies.  Justices reject tribal immunity from bankruptcy stay.
Scott Waterman
November 12, 2023
If you intend to seek to discharge student loans under §523(a)(8), do not consolidate the loans after the case is filed. Prebankruptcy planning is most important if one wishes to discharge student loans. A recent Texas Chapter 7 case highlights the pitfalls if one does not act accordingly. Debtors obtained 27 separate student loans prior to when they filed their...

Looking to Become a Member?

ConsiderChapter13.org offers a forum to advance continuing education of consumer bankruptcy via access to insightful articles, informative webinars, and the latest industry news. Join now to benefit from expert resources and stay informed.


These informative sessions are led by industry experts and cover a range of consumer bankruptcy topics.

Member Articles

Written by industry experts, these articles provide in-depth analysis and practical guidance on consumer bankruptcy topics.

Industry News

The Academy is the go-to source for the latest news and analysis in the Chapter 13 bankruptcy industry.

To get started, please let us know which of these best fits your current position: