Johnson v. Zimmer, 686 F.3d 224, 230–40 (4th Cir. 2012) (Wilkinson, King, Agee)

Rejecting “heads on beds” and “income tax dependent” approaches, “economic unit” is proper method to determine household size and fractional children are considered. “[Section] 707(b) means test calculation will be affected by the threshold determination of how many people are part of her ‘household,’ as determined for purposes of § 1325(b). . . . [I]t is not immediately clear how to define ‘family’ even as part of the determination of a ‘household.’ . . . Because the term ‘household’ ‘lends itself to more than one reasonable interpretation,’ it is ambiguous. . . . [N]othing in § 1325(b) directly or indirectly incorporates the Census Bureau’s definition of ‘household.’ . . . [T]he heads-on-beds approach . . . is wholly unrelated to any bankruptcy purpose and does not serve the Code’s objective of identifying a debtor’s deductible monthly expenses and, ultimately, his or her disposable income. . . . It makes little sense to allow debtors to broadly define their ‘households’ so as to include individuals who have no actual financial impact on the debtor’s expenses. . . . [U]nlike the heads-on-beds approach, the economic unit approach is consistent with § 1325(b), the BAPCPA, and the Code as a whole. By examining the financial interdependence of individuals to determine whether someone is an economic part of the debtor’s household, bankruptcy courts are able to avoid over- and under-inclusive results that would result by artificially defining ‘household’ according to factors unrelated to which individuals within a residence impact the debtor’s financial situation. . . . Under this method, a debtor’s ‘household’ would include individuals who operate as an ‘economic unit’ with the debtor . . . . In contrast to the ‘economic unit’ approach, the income tax dependent approach fails to match the goals of the BAPCPA and the Code. . . . [T]he income tax dependent approach tends to be under-inclusive for purposes of ascertaining a debtor’s household size and disposable income. . . . [D]ividing individuals into fractional members of a household is less than ideal. At the same time, we recognize that the Debtor’s situation is increasingly common in modern American life, and that the number of individuals with a financial relationship to a debtor may well vary depending on the day of the week and other circumstances.”

No Author Biography has been linked to this Article.

Related Articles

Molly Pro picture
August 28, 2022
If you put your ear to the ground you may hear the rumblings regarding a change to Bankruptcy Rule 3002.1 requiring the institution of a mid-case bankruptcy audit. This mid-case audit would be like the Notice of Final Cure but would be performed by a trustee’s office in the middle of a pending Chapter 13, rather than at the end,...
Members
September 19, 2021
By Helen M. Morris, Chapter 13 Standing Trustee for the Northern and Southern Districts of West Virginia Like most trustees, my case load is down, and I’ve been actively encouraging new filings. Perhaps too enthusiastically as certain new cases reflect. A bankruptcy filer who has been dormant for months filed a new case recently. Schedule A is clearly marked with...
Members
September 26, 2021
By Lawrence R. Ahern III, Brown & Ahern (Nashville, TN) "Equity is not an old man, with a long grey beard, sitting under a tree. Equity has rules."1 Introduction Section 105 When enacted in 1978, the Bankruptcy Code in section 105 included an "all writs" statute for the Bankruptcy Courts: The court may issue any order, process, or judgment that...
Members
February 9, 2020
By The Honorable William Houston Brown (Retired) Failure to include creditor on matrix not grounds to extend time for proof of claim. The Chapter 13 debtor had timely filed her list of creditors, pursuant to Rule 1007(a), but she failed to include a creditor either on that list or in the schedules, resulting in the creditor not receiving notice of...
Members
September 25, 2022
Just prior to a confirmation docket in September of 2006, a local creditor attorney asked me if I would be interested in coming to work at his firm. The chapter 13 trustee was in the room and could not help but overhear. After the docket that trustee asked me if I was looking for a job. I wasn’t . ....
June 7, 2020
By The Honorable William Houston Brown (Retired) Hardship discharge denied. Section 1328(b)’s requirements for hardship discharge are conjunctive and failure to satisfy any one of three conditions results in denial. Reviewing judicial decisions on requirements of the statute, the court considered “the extent of a debtor’s accountability and degree of control; the substantiality and foreseeability of the changed circumstances at...
Members
January 20, 2019
By John P. Gustafson, United States Bankruptcy Judge, Northern District of Ohio, Western Division (Toledo, OH) Click here for Part 1 of 6 Click here for Part 2 of 6 Click here for Part 3 of 6
Members
enmark
October 22, 2023
This quick read has something for everyone. “The services are convenient for consumers and probably encourage impulse buying.” More from this author: Post-Confirmation Property & Income Changes
Members
March 20, 2022
“The trouble with retirement is that you never get a day off!” [Abe Lemons] There is no better way to describe Robert Wilson in his career as an attorney, as a trustee, in his life thus far, and surely in his retirement! He has filled and will continue to fill every second of every day with meaning and purpose and...
KIMBALL
October 8, 2023
“In most cases, debtor’s counsel addresses only the argument that the debtor’s personal or financial affairs have substantially changed since dismissal of the preceding case.”
Members

Looking to Become a Member?

ConsiderChapter13.org offers a forum to advance continuing education of consumer bankruptcy via access to insightful articles, informative webinars, and the latest industry news. Join now to benefit from expert resources and stay informed.

Webinars

These informative sessions are led by industry experts and cover a range of consumer bankruptcy topics.

Member Articles

Written by industry experts, these articles provide in-depth analysis and practical guidance on consumer bankruptcy topics.

Industry News

The Academy is the go-to source for the latest news and analysis in the Chapter 13 bankruptcy industry.

To get started, please let us know which of these best fits your current position: