In re Coay, No. 09-71814, 2012 WL 2319100, at *5–*8 (Bankr. C.D. Ill. June 19, 2012) (Gorman)

Trustee’s motion to modify confirmed plan to increase payments to unsecured creditors based on tax return showing increased income is rejected: disposable income calculation is not “reset” at modification under § 1329, and only ground stated by trustee for increase in payments is change in disposable income. “[B]ecause § 1325(b) is not one of the provisions identified in § 1329(b)(1) as applying to plan modifications, the issue arises whether the Trustee can require a resetting of the Debtors’ disposable income by filing a Motion to Amend. . . . [S]ince the enactment of BAPCPA, the calculation of disposable income yields a number as of confirmation that is not subject to change upon review at a later date when a modification is requested. . . . The Trustee concedes this point and . . . suggests that some nebulous formula of comparing income and expenses . . . should be used for calculating disposable income for plan modifications. But, there is no authority for that argument. . . . [Section] 1325(b) does not apply to plan modifications. To the extent the Trustee seeks to reset the Debtors’ disposable income under § 1325(b) by his Motion to Amend, the Motion must be denied. . . . Only one of the provisions of Chapter 13 which applies to plan modifications addresses the amounts which must be paid to unsecured creditors. . . . § 1325(a)(4) . . . . [A] hypothetical liquidation analysis must be performed in Chapter 13 cases . . . to obtain initial plan confirmation or approval of a plan modification. . . . [C]hanges in circumstances are relevant to the statutorily-created tests of good faith, best efforts or liquidation analysis, and feasibility, which all apply to plan modifications. . . . [C]hanges in circumstances related to income and expenses may be considered when reviewing proposed plan modifications. . . . The Trustee’s Motion to Amend is not premised on any of the Code provisions . . . . There is no authority for setting—or resetting—what Debtors must pay unsecured creditors other than the specific Code sections discussed above. . . . [T]he Trustee . . . has provided no proof that the Debtors here have the ability to pay any more than they already are paying.”

No Author Biography has been linked to this Article.

Related Articles

May 17, 2020
By The Honorable William Houston Brown (Retired) Sanctions for including foreclosed property in petition. On creditor’s motion, sanctions for attorney fees and costs were awarded against Chapter 13 debtor’s attorney for scheduling as property of estate real property that had been foreclosed and on which debtor’s redemption period had expired. Under Rule 9011(c), a safe harbor letter from the creditor...
Members
rmichaelsmith
September 18, 2022
As we observe the growing discussion over the tremendous amount of outstanding student loan debt, several points of clarification might do us well. There are those favoring relief for debtors now unable to pay their student loans. They have proposed various forms of relief, including several forgiveness programs and re-allowing such debts to be discharged in bankruptcy under more usual...
Members
finberg
September 10, 2023
Andrew B. Finberg has been appointed as a Chapter 13 Standing Trustee for the District of New Jersey.  Finberg is picking up the mantle left by happily retiring Isabel Balboa.
October 10, 2021
By Angela M. Scolforo, Staff Attorney to Herbert L. Beskin, Chapter 13 Trustee for the Western District of Virginia Since January 2019 alone there have been about 250 student loan discharge cases decided in the federal courts.1 One site reports that student loan debt in the United States totals $1.73 trillion, across 43.2 million borrowers, and the debt is growing6...
Members
branson1
The Justice Department, in partnership with the Department of Education, recently announced new guidelines that loosen the strict application of the “undue hardship” exceptionwhen defending a student loan dischargeability action. This new guidance is a game changer. In the past the Department of Justice narrowly applied the undue hardship exception when defending discharge of student loans to the extent that...
Members
June 16, 2019
By Jan Hamilton, Chapter 13 Trustee (Topeka, KS) Click here for Part 1 of 3 8. Early Preparation for Trial As suggested, the best way to settle a case is to be willing to try that case, which means you must prepare from the get go. That preparation begins a long time before the eve of trial, namely, at the...
Members
May 17, 2020
By Marsha M. Brown, Staff Attorney to Chapter 13 Trustee Douglas W. Neway (Jacksonville, FL) We talk about it daily - emailing issues back and forth as to what is reasonable and what is not. Should every Court have a basic reasonable fee structure or should every attorney be required to file an application to prove the reasonableness of his/her...
Members
ncbj4
Judge Deborah Thorne, NDIL, and Judge Kathy Surratt-States, EDMO, on behalf of the NCBJ’s DEI Committee, have written two articles about some of judicial firsts.
moran_cathy
February 11, 2024
Communications Practice Pointer! Convincing clients that all of their debts must be included in bankruptcy is one of the hardest parts of being a bankruptcy lawyer. Communicating clearly with our clients, in their language, is a key part of our job. The struggle often seems Herculean.
Members
March 3, 2019
By William Houston Brown, United States Bankruptcy Judge, Retired; Editor/Adviser, The Academy On April 1, 2019, an increase takes effect in those dollar amounts in the Bankruptcy Code that are subject to adjustment every three years.1 The following increases have significance in everything from the eligibility maximums for filing under Chapters 12 and 13 to the debtor’s exemptions. Relevant Official...

Looking to Become a Member?

ConsiderChapter13.org offers a forum to advance continuing education of consumer bankruptcy via access to insightful articles, informative webinars, and the latest industry news. Join now to benefit from expert resources and stay informed.

Webinars

These informative sessions are led by industry experts and cover a range of consumer bankruptcy topics.

Member Articles

Written by industry experts, these articles provide in-depth analysis and practical guidance on consumer bankruptcy topics.

Industry News

The Academy is the go-to source for the latest news and analysis in the Chapter 13 bankruptcy industry.

To get started, please let us know which of these best fits your current position: