Benn And The Tax Refund Exemption In Bankruptcy Part II

(Reprinted with permission. Bankruptcy Law Network October 2011)

By Wendell Sherk, Missouri Bankruptcy Attorney

In the previous installment, we discussed the 8th Circuit’s Benn decision which began a sea change in Missouri bankruptcy exemptions.

To see how Benn‘s unusual opinion created  uncertainty in Missouri bankruptcies, one need look no further than our state teacher pension plans.  Prior to 2010, almost no one seriously imagined a state employee’s pension plan would be unprotected in bankruptcy.  Well-established pensions are like battleships, with layer after layer of armor protecting them from creditors typically.  And no single attack can get through.

In Missouri the pension plan law itself provides protection:

Neither the funds belonging to the retirement system nor any benefit accrued or accruing to any person…shall be subject to execution, garnishment, attachment or any other process whatsoever, nor shall they be assignable….  (169.090 RSMo.)

Yet Bankruptcy Judge Arthur Federman of the Western District of Missouri applied Benn and found Missouri’s laws wanting.  He reasoned Benn‘s reading of the Bankruptcy Code command that the state’s lawmakers use precise language — “magic words” in lawyer parlance — in order for a law to be an exemption in bankruptcy cases.

Benn said:

“Exemption” is a term of art in bankruptcy, and we agree with the dissenting judge of the BAP that “[w]hile exemption may mean different things in different contexts, in the context of Sec. 522, it refers to laws enacted by the legislative branch which explicitly identify property [that] judgment-debtors can keep away from creditors for reasons of public policy. (Benn at 814)

It is interesting to note however that the Bankruptcy Code itself does not actually define the word “exemption” but only defines how (and from what sources of law) a debtor may “exempt” property from the estate.

Judge Federman’s In re Nathan Smith opinion argues that the legislature enacted specific exemption laws for other pension plans but the teacher pension at issue did not use the magic word “exempt.”  And further the judge could find no legislative history to indicate the Missouri General Assembly intended to protect the pensions in bankruptcy cases.  (The lack of evidence is not surprising as the Missouri legislature does not maintain legislative history, though.)

Before any Missouri teacher panics, even Judge Federman acknowledges in a final footnote that there are other means than the statute at issue to preserve the pension in bankruptcy.  But he did expand on the dictum in the Benn decision and conclude that Missouri in fact does have a separate system of protections for consumers, inside or outside of bankruptcy, because the 8th Circuit “was quite clear that, in order to create an exemption in bankruptcy, the Missouri legislature must use that word [exemption].”

So prior to Benn, the laws of exemptions had generally been interpreted expansively to benefit the debtor because bankruptcy is considered a remedial process to help debtors obtain a fresh start. Indeed, prior to Benn, this same statute had been upheld as a bankruptcy exemption in In re Olson, 108 B.R. 232 (Bankr.W.D.Mo. 1989).  Indeed, the ruling seems to presuppose that the pension plan was even property of the estate, which seems unlikely under the Supreme Court’s 1992 Patterson v. Shumate decision.

Yet after Benn, the law of exemption became a narrowly-defined process.  In the next installment, we’ll discuss other issues created and then how things may recover in the future.

Wendell J. Sherk is an attorney in St. Louis, practicing primarily in consumer bankruptcy and debtor representation. He graduated from Washington University in 1986 and Washington University School of Law in 1989. He is a principal of the firm Sherk & Swope, LLC as well as a member of the National Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys, American Bankruptcy Institute, and The Missouri Bar. He contributes to the blog and his e-mail is: [email protected].

No Author Biography has been linked to this Article.

Related Articles

November 19, 2023
On Thanksgiving, I’m mindful of how precious the American approach to insolvency is.
February 3, 2019
By John P. Gustafson, United States Bankruptcy Judge, Northern District of Ohio, Western Division (Toledo, OH) Click here for Part 1 Click here for Part 2 Click here for Part 3
May 14, 2023
(Reprinted with permission.  Bankruptcy Court Liaison Committee Newsletter – Spring 2023 (Northern District of Illinois)) During her tenure as a bankruptcy judge for nearly 24 years, Judge Carol A. Doyle has presided over countless chapter 7, 11, and 13 cases, leaving a lasting impact on the Chicago bankruptcy landscape.  She has been a dedicated and respected member of the bankruptcy...
Copy of Hildebrand-2016
December 18, 2022
Where a debtor fails to disclose to the Court or the trustee a forbearance on his mortgage that he was to pay directly, the Court would grant the trustee’s motion to modify to recapture as much as possible of the surplus funds the forbearance generated. (Kenney) In re Ilyev, 2022 WL 2965029 (Bankr. E.D. Va. July 26, 2022) Case Summary...
September 10, 2023
The Ninth Circuit BAP held that the chapter 13 debtors converted their case to Chapter 7 in good faith and therefore a post-petition inheritance was not property of the chapter 7 estate.
March 21, 2021
By The Honorable William Houston Brown (Retired) For modification purposes, best interests test remains at petition date. In an examination of post-confirmation sale of the debtor’s home that yielded excess of homestead exemption, the Court concluded that the best-interests of creditors’ calculation was performed as of the petition date, rather than time of modification. Section 1329 does not provide a...
May 12, 2019
By Robert B. Branson and Tammy Branson, Branson Law PLLC (Orlando, FL) Congress’ goal of bankruptcy is for the honest debtor to get a fresh start. Since most federally guaranteed student loans are nondischargeable, the current outcome is a “false start” instead of a fresh start. Resolving a $1.5 trillion student loan crisis is problematic in that the caselaw was...
August 20, 2023
Wishing our dear friend and colleague, Isabel Balboa, a hearty congratulations on her upcoming retirement. As many of you know, Isabel came to the United States from Cuba at the age of 6 with her mother and sisters.  Upon leaving Cuba, they were forced to leave everything behind for fear that they would be caught and detained.  Her father was...
January 6, 2019
By John P. Gustafson, United States Bankruptcy Judge, Northern District of Ohio, Western Division (Toledo, OH) Click here for Part 1 of 6 Click here for Part 3 of 6 Click here for Part 4 of 6 Click here for Part 5 of 6 Click here for Part 6 . . . It looks like you are not signed in...
April 28, 2024
“Although exemptions are meant to be interpreted liberally; this issue may become increasingly complex with the rise of remote work such as traveling nurses.”

Looking to Become a Member? offers a forum to advance continuing education of consumer bankruptcy via access to insightful articles, informative webinars, and the latest industry news. Join now to benefit from expert resources and stay informed.


These informative sessions are led by industry experts and cover a range of consumer bankruptcy topics.

Member Articles

Written by industry experts, these articles provide in-depth analysis and practical guidance on consumer bankruptcy topics.

Industry News

The Academy is the go-to source for the latest news and analysis in the Chapter 13 bankruptcy industry.

To get started, please let us know which of these best fits your current position: